Pakistan’s fight against terrorism cannot be won through security operations alone. It requires confronting the financial networks, political protection, administrative complicity and criminal economies that enable terrorist organisations to survive, expand and target the very institutions responsible for protecting the country. The revelations surrounding illegal gold mining along the Kohat-to-Nowshera stretch of the River Indus, highlighted during Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Governor Faisal Karim Kundi’s press briefing, have brought this uncomfortable reality into sharp focus.
What has emerged is far more disturbing than a case of unauthorised mineral extraction. It raises serious questions about the relationship between organised criminal interests, political figures, government officials, law enforcement personnel and terrorist organisations. If the allegations and financial estimates presented in the discussion are established through an independent investigation, the illegal mining network could represent one of the most serious examples of how a criminal economy can undermine governance, deprive the public treasury of billions of rupees and potentially provide financial support to militant groups.
The gravity of the situation becomes even more apparent when viewed alongside the recent sacrifices of police personnel and the successful intelligence-based operations conducted by Pakistan’s security forces in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan. These developments are interconnected. On one side, security personnel are sacrificing their lives to eliminate terrorism; on the other, allegations have surfaced that powerful interests may have been protecting criminal activities capable of generating resources for those threatening the state.
This contradiction demands an uncompromising response.
The controversy surrounding illegal gold mining between Kohat and Nowshera is not a matter that can be dismissed as an isolated incident. The issue had reportedly been highlighted months before the recent confrontation, when concerns were raised about unauthorised mining along different sections of the river, particularly Blocks C and D.
The activity involved the search and extraction of placer gold, with heavy machinery reportedly being used along the riverbanks. Despite repeated warnings and public attention, the illegal operations allegedly continued without meaningful intervention.
An earlier investigation had reportedly identified four companies or contractors that had received contracts worth approximately Rs4 billion. Questions were raised about the legality of these arrangements and the manner in which they were awarded. Yet the machinery continued operating, and the alleged illegal extraction expanded.
The most alarming estimate presented during the discussion was that illegal mining in the relevant areas could be generating approximately Rs2 billion every month. If this estimate is accurate, the annual financial volume would reach an astonishing Rs24 billion. This is an enormous amount of money, particularly for a province facing economic difficulties, security challenges, unemployment and pressure on public services.
The central question is straightforward: how could an operation of this scale continue for such an extended period without the knowledge of the relevant administrative authorities? Thousands of excavators, tractors, trolleys and other pieces of machinery cannot operate secretly in an area under government jurisdiction. Such an extensive operation requires transportation, fuel, manpower, logistical arrangements and access to mining locations. It also requires a degree of protection from interference.
The removal of approximately 7,000 to 7,800 pieces of machinery from the affected locations during the recent action illustrates the extraordinary scale of the operation. The reported presence of another 600 to 800 pieces of machinery at different locations further suggests that the problem cannot be considered completely resolved. The question is no longer simply who was extracting gold illegally. The more important question is who allowed them to do so, who benefited financially, and who ensured that the law remained ineffective.
One of the most significant aspects of Governor Faisal Karim Kundi’s briefing was the reported identification of individuals associated with different political backgrounds. The names discussed included former provincial minister and PTI figure Amjad Afridi, Jamiat Ulema-e-Islam’s Gohar Saifullah, advocate Hammad Hassan and Naseem Afridi, who was reportedly associated with a JUI electoral ticket.
These are serious allegations that require careful investigation, documentary evidence and the opportunity for every individual concerned to respond. Merely naming someone in a press briefing does not establish criminal responsibility. Nevertheless, the public has every right to demand that allegations involving politically influential individuals be investigated without discrimination.
The significance of this controversy lies partly in the fact that the allegations are not confined to a single political party. Political differences often dominate Pakistan’s public discourse. Parties accuse one another of corruption, incompetence and political manipulation, while their supporters defend their respective leaderships. However, when allegations emerge that individuals associated with different political camps may have benefited from the same illegal economic activity, the issue transcends conventional party politics.
No political affiliation should provide immunity from investigation. No former minister, elected representative, party office-holder or influential local figure should be considered untouchable.Governor Kundi’s decision to publicly identify individuals reportedly associated with different political backgrounds is particularly significant because it places accountability above partisan considerations. However, the real test will not be the announcement of names. It will be whether the relevant institutions pursue the evidence to its logical conclusion. Pakistan has witnessed numerous controversies in which influential names have emerged in public discussions, only for investigations to lose momentum once political pressure intensifies. This case must not become another example of allegations without consequences.
The financial dimension of the Kohat mining controversy makes it considerably more serious than an ordinary case of illegal extraction. During the discussion, the possibility was raised that a portion of the enormous revenue generated through illegal mining may have reached terrorist organisations, including the banned Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan.
The estimated amount potentially diverted towards militant networks was discussed in the range of Rs500 million to Rs2 billion annually. This was presented as an estimate rather than a verified financial figure, and it must be treated accordingly until supported by financial records and an independent investigation.
Nevertheless, the underlying concern deserves immediate attention. Terrorist organisations require money to maintain their networks, acquire weapons, arrange transportation, recruit members, provide logistical support and sustain their operational infrastructure. They cannot function indefinitely without access to financial resources. Where an illegal economic enterprise operates on such a large scale, the possibility that criminal beneficiaries may use part of their profits to purchase protection from armed groups or satisfy their financial demands must be thoroughly examined.
There are several possible dimensions to this relationship. First, illegal mining operators may have financed local protection networks to prevent interference with their activities. Second, individuals within administrative or law enforcement structures may have received financial benefits to ignore illegal extraction. Third, militant organisations may have demanded payments from those operating in areas where they possess influence. Fourth, criminal operators may have maintained relationships with different influential groups to ensure that their business continued without interruption. These possibilities demonstrate why the investigation must extend beyond the individuals physically operating the machinery.
The real objective should be to follow the money, identify its recipients and establish whether any portion of the proceeds reached terrorist organisations. If evidence establishes that money generated through illegal mining was used to finance attacks against Pakistani police officers and security personnel, the matter would constitute an exceptionally grave national security offence. It would mean that a criminal enterprise was not merely stealing the province’s natural resources but potentially helping finance violence against the state. Such conduct must be examined under all applicable criminal and counterterrorism laws.
The recent confrontation in Kohat has exposed the human cost of allowing criminal networks and militant elements to operate in an environment of impunity. Police personnel reportedly went to the area to remove illegal mining machinery. After completing their action, they came under armed attack while returning.
The banned Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan subsequently claimed responsibility for the attack. Reports discussed during the briefing referred to approximately 11 to 12 police personnel losing their lives. Their sacrifice must never be reduced to a passing news headline.
These officers were performing their official responsibilities. They were attempting to enforce the law against an illegal operation that had reportedly continued despite earlier warnings. Their deaths underline a deeply troubling reality: when criminal interests become sufficiently powerful, law enforcement personnel can find themselves confronting not only individual offenders but also armed networks capable of organising lethal retaliation.
The state must therefore ensure that the investigation into the Kohat incident examines every possible connection between illegal mining operators, local facilitators, administrative officials and the militant organisation that claimed responsibility.
It is equally important to investigate whether the attack was planned in advance, whether information about the police operation was leaked and whether anyone facilitated the attackers. The families of the martyred officers deserve more than official condolences. They deserve justice, transparency and the assurance that those responsible, including anyone who provided financial or logistical assistance, will face the law.
Perhaps the most important unanswered question concerns the role of the provincial administration. How could such extensive mining continue without attracting the attention of assistant commissioners, deputy commissioners, commissioners and relevant police officials? The operation reportedly involved thousands of pieces of heavy machinery and generated enormous sums of money. Such activity would have required movement across roads, access to riverbanks and the cooperation of multiple local networks.
It is therefore essential to investigate whether government officials failed to perform their duties through negligence, received financial benefits or deliberately facilitated the operation. The same scrutiny must apply to police personnel and officers responsible for maintaining law and order in the affected areas. The allegations discussed during the briefing reportedly extend to bureaucratic and police circles, with certain officials also being identified as potential subjects of investigation. This is where the proposed judicial commission becomes particularly important.
A credible commission must not simply collect statements and produce another report that disappears into government files. It must establish a clear chain of responsibility, examine relevant contracts, scrutinise financial transactions, identify beneficiaries and recommend legal action wherever evidence supports it.
The investigation should also determine how the alleged four billion rupees in contracts were awarded, whether the contractual arrangements were lawful and which authorities were responsible for monitoring their implementation.
Above all, the commission must operate independently of political influence. If influential individuals are implicated, they should face the same legal process as ordinary citizens. If government officials are found to have facilitated illegal extraction, their positions must not protect them from prosecution. The suspension of illegal mining is an important initial step, but a prohibition alone cannot dismantle an established criminal economy. The machinery must be accounted for, the financial trail investigated and the illegal supply networks permanently disrupted.
While the Kohat controversy has exposed the alleged financial foundations of criminal and militant networks, the recent security operations in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan demonstrate the state’s determination to confront terrorism through decisive action. The discussion highlighted successful intelligence-based operations in areas including Orakzai, North Waziristan and Balochistan, in which approximately 90 to 94 militants were reportedly killed, while 37 others were injured.
These operations represent a significant development in Pakistan’s continuing counterterrorism campaign. Intelligence-based operations are particularly important because they enable security forces to act against identified militant positions, networks and hideouts rather than relying exclusively on broad security deployments.
The reported scale of the recent operations suggests intensified efforts to dismantle militant infrastructure and deny terrorist organisations the freedom to operate in areas where they have previously maintained a presence. However, eliminating militants through military action is only one dimension of a successful counterterrorism strategy.
The larger challenge is ensuring that terrorist organisations cannot return to the same areas, rebuild their networks or exploit local grievances to recruit new members. This requires sustained intelligence gathering, effective policing, administrative control and public cooperation. A successful operation should therefore be measured not only by the number of militants killed or arrested but also by the state’s ability to prevent the re-emergence of militant networks.
One of the most important points emerging from the discussion is that terrorism cannot flourish without an enabling environment. Militant organisations require places to stay, logistical assistance, financial support, intelligence about security movements and individuals willing to provide protection.
Such assistance may come from ideological supporters, criminal networks, financially motivated individuals or people who believe they can use militant organisations to protect their own commercial interests. The Kohat allegations illustrate why counterterrorism policy must extend beyond the battlefield.
If individuals are using political influence, administrative connections or illegal businesses to facilitate terrorist organisations, their activities must be investigated as part of the wider national security response. The state must distinguish between ordinary political activity and criminal facilitation. Political disagreement is not terrorism, and association with a political party cannot itself establish criminal involvement. However, where credible evidence demonstrates that an individual has financed, sheltered or materially supported a banned terrorist organisation, the law must apply regardless of political status.
The same principle applies to bureaucrats, police officials, contractors and influential local figures. The proposed approach of intensifying action against terrorist hideouts and facilitators must be accompanied by a transparent legal framework. Anyone found guilty of providing material support to terrorism must face appropriate legal consequences. At the same time, the protection of innocent civilians must remain central to all counterterrorism activities.
There is another important dimension to Pakistan’s security challenge: the relationship between the public and state institutions. In areas affected by terrorism, citizens must have confidence that the police, administration, courts and security institutions are working in their interests. This confidence cannot be established through force alone. It requires fairness, transparency, effective service delivery and equal enforcement of the law.
When people witness powerful individuals allegedly benefiting from illegal economic activities while ordinary citizens face the consequences of insecurity, public trust inevitably suffers. When police officers lose their lives enforcing the law, but influential beneficiaries of illegal operations appear beyond accountability, the credibility of the entire governance system is placed at risk.
The state must therefore combine security operations with meaningful governance reforms. Local communities should be encouraged to cooperate with law enforcement through lawful reporting mechanisms and protection against intimidation. The administration must address legitimate public concerns, while security institutions must demonstrate professionalism and restraint. No community should be collectively blamed for the presence of terrorists in its territory. Responsibility belongs to those who commit, facilitate or knowingly support criminal activities. A strong relationship between citizens and state institutions can help deny militant organisations the social space they need to survive.
The alleged Rs24 billion annual scale of illegal mining deserves attention beyond the immediate question of terrorism financing. Natural resources belong to the public. Their extraction must take place within the law, under transparent contractual arrangements and with proper revenue collection.
If such a significant volume of gold extraction is taking place outside the legal framework, the provincial government is potentially losing substantial public revenue that could otherwise support infrastructure, education, healthcare, policing and development in underserved areas. The financial losses are not merely accounting figures. They represent missed opportunities for communities that need better public services and economic opportunities. The government should therefore establish the actual quantity of gold extracted, the market value of the production, the identities of those who purchased it and the amount of revenue that should legally have been deposited into the public treasury.
Any assets acquired through proven illegal proceeds should be dealt with under applicable law. The ultimate objective must be to ensure that natural resources generate public prosperity rather than private fortunes for criminal networks.
The developments surrounding Kohat and the recent counterterrorism operations present the government with an important opportunity.
The ban on illegal mining, the proposed judicial commission and the public identification of individuals allegedly connected with the activity are significant steps. However, their credibility will depend entirely on implementation.
The investigation must answer five fundamental questions:
- Who authorised, facilitated or protected the illegal mining operations?
- Which political, administrative and police figures benefited from the activity?
- Where did the billions of rupees generated through illegal extraction ultimately go?
- Did any financial resources reach the banned Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan or other militant organisations?
- Who planned, facilitated and executed the attack on police personnel who went to remove the machinery?
These questions cannot be answered through political statements alone. They require financial investigations, documentary evidence, witness protection, forensic examination and independent judicial oversight.
The government must also ensure that the remaining machinery is dealt with lawfully, illegal extraction does not resume under another arrangement and all legitimate mining activity follows transparent legal procedures.
The same determination must continue in counterterrorism operations across Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan. Military successes must be consolidated through effective administration, intelligence cooperation and public confidence.





