Indian media’s attempt to link the Gurdaspur explosives and criminal-network incident to Pakistan’s premier intelligence agency, the Inter-Services Intelligence (ISI), has triggered fresh questions about irresponsible journalism, sensationalism and the persistent tendency to attribute India’s internal security failures to Pakistan without presenting credible evidence.
The controversy has intensified following a report by Indian television channel Zee News, which attempted to establish a Pakistani connection to the Gurdaspur incident despite the absence of publicly disclosed, independently verifiable evidence demonstrating any involvement of Pakistan or its intelligence agencies.
The incident has once again raised concerns about the tendency of sections of the Indian media to introduce a cross-border narrative before investigations have established the facts, identities of those involved and the actual sources of the recovered explosive material.
Questions have emerged over the rationale behind immediately invoking Pakistan when the individuals under investigation, the criminal connections and the alleged sources of explosive material are being examined within a local context.
Critics have questioned why Pakistan and Islamabad are being implicated before the investigation has established a credible foreign connection.
If the individuals involved belong to local criminal networks and the investigation concerns locally sourced material, any claim of foreign involvement must be supported by concrete evidence rather than speculation or television narratives.
The central question remains: what verifiable evidence connects the Gurdaspur incident to Pakistan or the ISI?
Zee News has faced criticism over its coverage of the incident, particularly for promoting a narrative involving Pakistani handlers without publicly establishing the evidentiary basis for such claims.
Media analysts and critics argue that presenting an unverified foreign-handling theory as a plausible explanation risks misleading audiences, inflaming public sentiment and undermining the integrity of an ongoing investigation.
The practice of introducing Pakistan’s name whenever a security-related incident occurs in India raises serious questions about journalistic standards and the distinction between investigative reporting and speculative commentary.
Responsible journalism demands verification, corroboration and transparency. A television channel cannot substitute speculation for evidence or turn an unresolved criminal investigation into an opportunity for political sensationalism.
According to claims cited by Pakistani sources, more than 100 incidents during 2026 have been linked to the ISI in Indian media and official narratives, ranging from alleged train-related explosions to local criminal activities.
Such a pattern raises important questions about the evidentiary standards being applied when Indian authorities and media organisations attribute domestic security incidents to Pakistan.
If credible evidence exists in these cases, it should be presented through transparent investigative findings, forensic reports and verifiable intelligence rather than repeated assertions and television discussions.
Critics have also questioned why alleged foreign connections frequently become prominent in public discourse after incidents occur, rather than being established through demonstrable preventive intelligence and investigative findings.
The controversy has also brought renewed attention to the challenges facing Indian Punjab, including drug trafficking, organised crime, gang violence and the activities of criminal networks.
These issues require effective policing, intelligence coordination, forensic investigation and accountability within India’s own security institutions.
Pakistan has consistently rejected attempts to attribute local criminal activity to foreign intelligence agencies without credible evidence. Domestic criminal networks must be investigated on their own merits, and responsibility must be established through facts rather than political convenience.
Blaming an external country cannot substitute for addressing internal law-enforcement failures.
Pakistan’s position remains clear: any claim of Pakistani involvement in the Gurdaspur incident must be substantiated through credible and independently verifiable evidence.
Those making such accusations should disclose:
- The identities of the alleged Pakistani handlers and their established connections with the suspects.
- Verified communications records demonstrating direct contact with individuals in Pakistan.
- Financial transactions, funding channels and traceable transfers allegedly linked to the incident.
- Forensic and investigative findings establishing the origin of the explosives and any foreign connection.
- Evidence demonstrating an institutional link to Pakistan’s intelligence agencies.
In the absence of such evidence, allegations against Pakistan or the ISI remain unsubstantiated and should not be presented as established facts.
Pakistan rejects attempts to exploit local criminal incidents for anti-Pakistan propaganda. The recurring practice of searching for an imaginary Pakistani handler behind every domestic crime does nothing to strengthen India’s internal security or establish the truth.
Instead of encouraging sensationalist narratives, Indian authorities and media organisations should prioritise transparent investigations, expose local criminal networks and establish responsibility through credible evidence.





